Full Title: Grace Under Fire: Choosing Unity in Divisive Times
Scriptures: Isaiah 40:29–31; John 17:20–23
Theme:
In a world marked by division, anxiety, and rapid change, followers of Christ are called to embody grace under pressure through unity, courageous conversation, and Spirit-led presence. Drawing on the prophet Isaiah’s promise to the exiled and Jesus’ prayer for His disciples, this sermon invites believers to reject the “either/or trap,” embrace a Spirit-led third way, and become bridges of reconciliation in a polarized culture.

---

Let me begin with a story about Evelyn and Helen—two sisters who seemed ancient to my childhood eyes. They were gentle, grace-filled women who moved through life with quiet dignity. Yet Evelyn, I’m told, had one small flaw: she needed to be right. One day, Helen admired a passerby’s dress, saying, “What a lovely blue!” Evelyn countered, “It’s green.” Helen offered, “Perhaps greenish blue?” Evelyn doubled down, “Bluish-green.” Evelyn loved to draw others into debate—and she loved to win. Sound familiar?

We see this impulse magnified today—not just between siblings, but between friends, parents and children, neighbor and neighbor. Relationships once anchored in peace now strain under this current culture of division. It is no secret to anyone here that we are living under pressure. You can feel it in the air, taste it in your morning coffee—before the headlines even find you—that dull, ever-present hum of anxiety.

We inhabit a world where the earth itself seems to sigh under the strain—storms churning, hearts hardening, people turning away instead of toward each other. Scroll for five minutes on social media and soon you will see the outrage, the sharp words, the careful choosing of sides. Listen to the news and you will hear it—this shorthand for pain with no easy solutions.

New technologies—artificial intelligence among them—arrive at dizzying speed, changing the very fabric of what we can, after seeing it with our own eyes, believe as truth. What can be trusted anymore? Recently, a friend confided, “I keep my thoughts to myself now, because I don’t feel safe sharing.” Many of us understand that instinct.

This is what pressure feels like. And when pressure builds, our reflex can be to retreat and compartmentalize our lives. In one space, I am a Christian. Outside these doors, I am an American. In some spaces, I am a daughter… or a sister… or a pastor. Sometimes, I am part of a political party with specific ideals. We move from one compartment to another, constantly judging our place and testing our audience for safety, so as not to cause friction. But here is a truth worth remembering: Jesus never lived that way—and He never asked us to live this way.

Part of our weariness comes from what I call the “either/or trap.” So much of our public conversation these days demands a choice: we are for or against, right or wrong, with them or against them. This binary framing draws battle lines that make understanding nearly impossible. But the Gospel invites us to something far richer—a Spirit-led third way. A way that doesn’t erase differences but refuses to make love and unity contingent on agreement. It treasures relationship over winning and builds bridges where division says, “No crossing.”

God has spoken into pressured times before. The Word we heard today was forged in the fires of history—not written during quiet ease, but when God’s people felt the weight of fear, division, and uncertainty pressing down. In Isaiah 40, Israel is in exile. Their holy city has fallen, the temple lies in ruins, and they live far from home under foreign rule. Exhaustion runs deep. Into that weariness comes the voice of the prophet: “He gives strength to the weary and increases the power of the weak… Those who hope in the Lord will renew their strength. They will soar on wings like eagles; they will run and not grow weary; they will walk and not be faint.” Isaiah speaks not to the comfortable but to the displaced—not to the untroubled, but to the crushed-hearted. His words are God’s promise that exile is not the end of the story.

Fast forward to the upper room in John 17. Jesus knows His hour has come. The cross looms large, betrayal is already set in motion, and the disciples will soon scatter in fear. In that tender space before Gethsemane, He prays: “I pray… that all of them may be one, Father, just as you are in me and I am in you… so that the world may believe that you have sent me.” Unity here is not an abstract ideal—it is Christ’s plea for His friends in a world that’s about to fracture. Before enduring the agony of the cross, He asks the Father to bind His followers together in love, knowing their unity will testify to His grace when pressure and persecution rage against them.

And just as Jesus prayed for unity in those final hours before the cross, He modeled it in the way He chose and nurtured His disciples. Jesus lived under Roman occupation, where Pharisees and Sadducees debated law and traditions, zealots plotted revolution, and tax collectors worked for the empire their neighbors despised. Yet Jesus called Matthew—a tax collector—and Simon—a zealot—into the same inner circle. He didn’t erase their differences; He taught them to break bread at the same table. He bound them in love.

Our situation today is much like this. Imagine a river digging a deep divide between two mountains. On one mountain stands one group; on the other—their perceived enemies. Then a bridge appears. The river remains, but now… now there is a way across. Christ is that bridge. And when we stand in His grace, we become part of that bridge for others.

In our polarized culture, unity will not happen by accident—it requires courageous conversation. Greater minds than mine have developed this idea and study; if you wish to dive deeper, visit the Discipleship Ministries website and search for “Courageous Conversations.” I will give you a brief bird’s-eye view.

Remember my friend who no longer shares her thoughts for fear of causing harm? Many people are silencing themselves, afraid of saying the wrong thing. That fear is real—but silence can also keep us from the healing that honest, grace-filled dialogue can bring. At the same time, we must challenge ourselves to recognize how easily we enter conversations convinced of our rightness. Like Evelyn, we sometimes seek debate rather than dialogue.

Debates aim to win; dialogues aim to understand. Debate creates winners and losers; dialogue creates humility and connection. Our natural reaction to opposing beliefs is defensiveness, not curiosity. If we believe all people are made in the image of God, then we owe one another curiosity—because every belief is shaped by a backstory, a life lived in circumstances we may never have experienced.

This humble curiosity opens us to transformation. And transformation may mean that as we speak, listen, and pray together, we become willing to be disrupted by God’s grace—willing to leave an encounter more Christ-like than when we began—even if it changes our mind, our priority, our heart. Grace under fire is neither silence born of fear nor speech born of arrogance—it is Spirit-led presence.

So how do we live into that presence? First, grace under fire begins with seeing the person before the position. Respecting someone’s humanity shifts the tone: there is no opponent, only another image-bearer of God. When Jesus met the woman at the well, He began not with accusation and argument but with a simple request for water, breaking cultural barriers between Jew and Samaritan, and between man and woman. In that moment, He affirmed her worth, invited mutual exchange, and showed that her identity mattered more than any societal divide.

Second, we listen with curiosity rather than preparing a rebuttal. Curiosity invites, “Tell me more,” while defensiveness responds, “Here is why you’re wrong.” Spirit-led listening seeks discovery, not victory—like Jesus on the road to Emmaus, walking with disciples and hearing their grief before revealing Himself. Though He could have ended their confusion immediately, He chose instead to walk alongside them, ask questions, and receive their pain. Entering their story built trust and created space for connection.

Third, we seek connection even in disagreement. Disagreement itself is not the real enemy—disconnection is. Unity is not uniformity. Jesus and the religious leaders, for example, disagreed about paying taxes. Rather than escalating the conflict, He pointed to both earthly and divine obligations, emphasizing higher principles. He consistently valued grace and transformation over winning arguments, moving from “us vs. them” to “all of us together” facing complex challenges, creating partners rather than opponents.

Finally, we create safe places for vulnerability. Here, hard truths can be spoken without humiliation, confidentiality is protected, and words are never turned into weapons. Jesus modeled this when He shielded the woman caught in adultery from public shame, choosing compassion over condemnation. Safe space invites honest conversation shaped by Christ’s love—listening without interruption, keeping confidences, and seasoning speech with grace rather than heat. True hospitality makes room for the stranger to become a friend; courageous conversation is that hospitality—speaking truth with love and hearing others without fear.

When faced with someone like Evelyn—someone who treats debate as sport and is driven by the need to win—courageous conversation may look different. Jesus often engaged such hearts with patience and discernment, speaking truth without being trapped in endless contests of pride. At times, He planted seeds and moved on, just as He instructed His disciples to “shake the dust” from their feet when a message was resisted. At other moments, He withdrew briefly, creating space for reflection before returning. The goal is neither to conquer nor to concede, but to embody grace that trusts God to work beyond the moment, knowing that truth shared in love can take root over time.

Think back to Isaiah, who promises renewal for those who hope in the Lord. We are not asked to solve every crisis—only to be faithful in what lies before us: holding hands, sharing meals, praying for those whose choices we don’t understand, and refusing to disconnect or let the division of binary thinking harden our hearts.

And so we step into conversations and relationships not as people who must win every argument, but as those entrusted with carrying Christ’s presence into the room. Our hope in the Lord keeps our hearts soft and our hands open, even when others resist or misunderstand. In choosing faithfulness over control, we quietly model the Kingdom, reminding a weary world that there is another way.

This is where our identity takes center stage. We are more than participants in dialogue—we are messengers of reconciliation, bearing the tone, the truth, and the tenderness of the One we follow. Church, this is grace under pressure: tender courage in the face of division, Spirit-filled speech in the midst of fear. Paul tells us in 2 Corinthians: “We are therefore Christ’s ambassadors, as though God were making His appeal through us.”

Imagine you had a business card identifying you as an ambassador for Christ. Imagine God’s appeal carried in your voice, your posture, and your presence. We leave here each week as bridge-builders, united in the One who prayed for our oneness. And in this confused and noisy world, the unity Jesus prayed over us will bind us together as one holy flame—a light that no darkness shall overcome.

Gracious and loving God, teach us again the way of Your Son. When we feel the pressure to choose sides, remind us of the bridge that is Christ. When the fires of conflict burn hot, let Your Spirit be the cool breath that steadies us. When fear overshadows us, save us from disconnection and engage us as people of courageous conversation. Bind us together, that the world would know we are Christians by our love. Amen and amen.